The Eye of Sauron: Raspberry filled glazed with orange frosting.
The One Ring: Raised Round Glazed
Mordor: That devils food one that no one likes and is always there.
Radagast: Frosted cake donut with shredded coconut
A baker’s dozen would be called a Fellowship.
”Hi I’d like a fellowship of donuts please. Let’s start with 2 One Rings, a Radagast, and 3 Morias.”
Donut holes could be Hobbits.
Day-olds should be called Gollums